Sec. 22a-285g. Negotiation.
Sec. 22a-285g. Negotiation. (a) Negotiation between the committee and the applicant shall begin after appointment of the members of the committee by each municipality
that received a notice under section 22a-285b or sixty days after receipt by each such
municipality of the notice, whichever is earlier and shall be completed within one hundred eighty days after commencement. The applicant shall negotiate with the committee
whose membership was selected by the time prescribed in section 22a-285f. After negotiations have begun, no municipality failing to appoint members to the committee within
the time specified in said section 22a-285f may appoint members unless the applicant
and the committee approves such appointments.
(b) The applicant and the municipal negotiating committee may negotiate on any
item, provided the provisions of this section shall not be construed to authorize the
negotiation of items that would be inconsistent with or render less stringent any requirements imposed by the commissioner. The negotiation of an agreement pursuant to this
section shall include, but not be limited to, discussion of the following: (1) Compensation
to any person for substantial economic effects that directly result from the ash residue
disposal area, as shown by a property value study conducted before and after construction of the ash residue disposal area; (2) reimbursement of reasonable costs incurred by
the committee for negotiation, mediation and arbitration in an amount greater than the
amount of the funds deposited pursuant to section 22a-285e; (3) screening and fencing
related to the appearance of the ash residue disposal area but not affecting its design
capacity; (4) operation of the ash residue disposal area, including, but not limited to,
noise, dust, debris, odors and hours, but excluding design capacity; (5) traffic flows and
patterns resulting from the facility; (6) site closure costs and site use after closure; (7)
payments to the municipality for road repair necessitated by traffic generated by the ash
residue disposal area; (8) establishment of a greenbelt buffer around the site for safety
and aesthetics, taking into account the site's proximity to residential areas; (9) purchase
of fire fighting equipment necessary at the site; (10) payments to the municipality for
actual police or fire costs; (11) funding of a municipal site monitoring program; and
(12) a compensation plan for the municipality in which the ash residue disposal area is
located. In no event shall total compensation for the negotiated items in subdivisions
(1) to (12), inclusive, of this section to the municipality in which such disposal area is
located be less than the equivalent of five dollars for each ton of ash to be deposited in
an ash residue disposal area. Any negotiated agreement approved or arbitration award
issued under this section shall contain provisions for resolving disputes in compliance
with the terms of such agreement or award.
(c) Either party may petition the council in writing to determine if a proposal may
be negotiated, provided such petition is submitted not more than ten days after the
proposal is offered. The council shall conduct a public hearing on the proposal and
issue a decision within fourteen days of the close of the hearing. The Commissioner of
Environmental Protection shall comment on the proposal. Pending the council's decision, negotiation may continue on any proposal, including the proposal that is the subject
of the petition.
(d) Negotiating sessions may be conducted with the assistance of a mediator if
mediation is approved by the applicant and the committee. The applicant or committee
may request a mediator at any time during the negotiation. A mediator shall encourage
voluntary settlement by the applicant and committee but shall not compel a settlement.
The applicant and the committee shall each pay one-half of the cost of mediation. The
council shall appoint a mediator if the applicant and the committee do not agree on the
selection of a mediator. The cost of the mediator to be paid by the committee shall be
divided equally among the municipalities with membership on the committee.
(e) Failure of the applicant or committee to participate in negotiating sessions constitutes default. Failure to participate shall not be construed to be default if such failure
is for good cause or because further negotiations cannot reasonably be expected to result
in a settlement. Either party may petition the council for a determination as to whether
a situation constitutes default. The council shall conduct a hearing on the matter. If no
committee members have been appointed by the time prescribed in section 22a-285f,
the committee shall be deemed to have defaulted. If the committee defaults, (1) the
authority may continue to seek any required permits and shall not be required to continue
to negotiate or arbitrate; (2) the site shall not be required to comply with any planning
or zoning provision adopted by the municipality in which it is located under chapter
124 or 126 or any special act, and (3) the council may make provisions for the defaulting
municipality regarding items specified in subsection (b) of this section. If the applicant
defaults, the council shall not issue an arbitration award.
(f) Any item resolved shall be included in a written negotiated agreement and submitted to the council for a determination of compliance with state law. Any item determined to violate state law shall be renegotiated and submitted to the council within
thirty days of the determination. The Commissioner of Environmental Protection shall
comment on the agreement. The agreement shall be binding if approved by the applicant
and the legislative body of the host municipality.
(g) If agreement on any issue is not reached within one hundred eighty days of the
beginning of negotiations between the applicant and the committee under subsection
(a) of this section or an agreement approved by the council is not approved by the
applicant or the legislative body of the municipality in which the ash residue disposal
area is located, the applicant may submit the matter to the council for arbitration. The
items specified in subsection (b) of this section shall be subject to arbitration.
(h) Not more than sixty days after a request for arbitration is submitted to the council
by the applicant pursuant to subsection (g) of this section, the parties shall submit their
final offers. A final offer of the committee shall be approved by the chief elected official
of each municipality in which the ash residue disposal area is located. Failure by either
party to submit a final offer shall constitute a default under subsection (e) of this section.
A final offer may include issues subject to arbitration and offered in negotiation but
shall not include items to which the parties have agreed. The applicant or the committee
shall not submit for arbitration any issue or proposal that was not presented during the
negotiation process unless both parties agree to the submittal. Not more than thirty days
after the last day for submitting final offers, the council shall conduct a hearing at which
the parties shall explain or present supporting arguments for their final offers. Negotiation may continue during arbitration.
(i) Not more than sixty days after accepting final offers, the council shall, by majority vote, issue an arbitration award. The council shall adopt without modification the
final offer of either party. Nothing in this section shall preclude the parties from entering
into an agreement after final offers have been submitted and prior to the issuance of an
award.
(j) Not more than fifteen days after the date of an arbitration award made under this
section, either party may appeal the award to the superior court for the judicial district
of Hartford. The superior court may affirm or deny the award or enter an order modifying
the award. Any appeal shall have precedence over all other civil actions in respect to
the order of trial, except as provided in sections 52-191 to 52-192, inclusive.
(k) The filing fee for an application for proceedings under this section shall be the
same as the filing fee for an application for a certificate for environmental capability
and public need under section 16-50l.
(l) No sooner than five years after the ash residue disposal area begins operation,
any of the items specified in subsection (a) of this section may be renegotiated if either
the applicant or an affected municipality petitions the council for renegotiation and
demonstrates to the satisfaction of the council substantial change in circumstances sufficient to justify such renegotiation. The council shall render a decision on such petition
within one hundred eighty days of receipt or at a time stated in the initial agreement
between the applicant and the affected municipalities.
(m) Nothing in sections 16-50j, 22a-208b and 22a-285 to 22a-285k, inclusive, shall
be construed as limiting the authority of the Commissioner of Environmental Protection
to impose conditions or other requirements on the construction, operation, closure or
postclosure care of an ash residue disposal area, and the conditions and requirements of
the commissioner shall supersede any provision of a negotiated or arbitrated agreement
between an applicant and an affected municipality which is inconsistent with or less
stringent than any condition or requirement of the commissioner.
(P.A. 88-230, S. 1, 12; P.A. 89-384, S. 9, 15; P.A. 90-98, S. 1, 2; P.A. 93-142, S. 4, 7, 8; P.A. 95-220, S. 4-6; P.A. 07-217, S. 114.)
History: (Revisor's note: P.A. 88-230 authorized substitution of "judicial district of Hartford" for "judicial district of
Hartford-New Britain" in public and special acts of the 1989 session, effective September 1, 1991); P.A. 90-98 changed
the effective date of P.A. 88-230 from September 1, 1991, to September 1, 1993; P.A. 93-142 changed the effective date
of P.A. 88-230 from September 1, 1993, to September 1, 1996, effective June 14, 1993; P.A. 95-220 changed the effective
date of P.A. 88-230 from September 1, 1996, to September 1, 1998, effective July 1, 1995; P.A. 07-217 made technical
changes in Subsec. (h), effective July 12, 2007.